Recorded votes on C2024-1045
Amendment at the Regular Meeting of Council, September 17, 2024. Carried 9–6.
Understand this policy choice
Resolution
That with respect to Verbal Report C2024-1045, the following amendment be adopted: That Council insert the following as a new Recommendation 4: Direct Administration to: Include the costs of Green Line Program wind down in the Mid-Cycle Adjustments so there is transparency for the public on costs associated with termination of the Program by the Government of Alberta; Return to Council by end of Q4 2024 with a legal opinion on how to transfer costs associated with wind down to the Government of Alberta, as their cancellation of the Green Line Program on September 3, 2024 triggered the termination of the project; Return to council with an option to consider first diverting any funds previously allocated to the Green Line towards presently unfunded Route Ahead priority public transit projects, provided any allocated funds remain following wind down; Draft a clear set of criteria by which the City of Calgary will consider engaging with the Government of Alberta on any future LRT project they propose to replace the Green Line Program, including but not limited to: A commitment from the Government of Canada to act as a funding partner; A commitment to a north-south LRT spine from 160th Avenue North to the community of Seton; A station immediately south of the Bow River in downtown Calgary to accomplish the goal of a contiguous north-south LRT spine; Identification of a bridge design to make the connection between north and south legs of the north-south LRT spine; Meaningful connections/stations serving the Beltline communities, the downtown and Red and Blue Line transfers west of Centre Street, and the Culture and Entertainment District; Use of modern low floor trains and stations for optimal accessibility; A maintenance and storage facility; Responsibility for delivery to be borne by the Government of Alberta; and Responsibility for all risks (financial, contractual, other) to be borne by the Government of Alberta; and e. Report back by end of Q1 2025 on the heritage preservation options for Ogden Block in light of the Government of Albertas termination of the Green Line project;
How each member voted
| Seat | Member | Vote |
|---|---|---|
| Mayor | Jyoti Gondek | Yes |
| Ward 1 | Sonya Sharp | No |
| Ward 2 | Jennifer Wyness | No |
| Ward 3 | Jasmine Mian | Yes |
| Ward 4 | Sean Chu | No |
| Ward 5 | Raj Dhaliwal | Yes |
| Ward 6 | Richard Pootmans | Yes |
| Ward 7 | Terry Wong | Yes |
| Ward 8 | Courtney Walcott | Yes |
| Ward 9 | Gian-Carlo Carra | Yes |
| Ward 10 | Andre Chabot | No |
| Ward 11 | Kourtney Penner | Yes |
| Ward 12 | Evan Spencer | No |
| Ward 13 | Dan McLean | No |
| Ward 14 | Peter Demong | Yes |
Recorded votes on C2024-1045
| Meeting | Motion | Result |
|---|---|---|
Sep 17, 2024 Regular Meeting of Council | Main motion Authorize the Green Line Board and City Administration to wind down the Program, given the project can no longer proceed as a result of the communication from the Province of Alberta dated 2024 Sep… | Carried 10–5 |
Sep 17, 2024 (this vote) Regular Meeting of Council | Amendment That Council insert the following as a new Recommendation 4: Direct Administration to: Include the costs of Green Line Program wind down in the Mid-Cycle Adjustments so there is transparency for th… | Carried 9–6 |
Sep 17, 2024 Regular Meeting of Council | Procedural With respect to Bylaw 6B2024 (Attachment 6), Reconsider giving first reading to bylaw 6B2024, | Carried 15–0 |
Sep 17, 2024 Regular Meeting of Council | Amendment That Recommendation 2 be amended by inserting the following words after the words Greenline LRT: , provided: The Government of Alberta provides a written commitment to transfer the delivery, financ… | Defeated 7–8 |
Sep 17, 2024 Regular Meeting of Council | Main motion Direct Administration to: Include the costs of Green Line Program wind down in the Mid-Cycle Adjustments so there is transparency for the public on costs associated with termination of the Program… | Defeated 2–13 |
Sep 17, 2024 Regular Meeting of Council | Bylaw reading Thank Calgarians, partners, the Green Line Board, Green Line Executive team and City Administration for their many years of hard work, commitment and dedication in advancing this project. Receive f… | Carried 15–0 |
Sep 17, 2024 Regular Meeting of Council | Amendment The amendment be further amended by inserting the words "prepare a scoping report to Council through Infrastructure and Planning Committee to consider undertaking the following work." following the… | Defeated 5–10 |
Sep 17, 2024 Regular Meeting of Council | Main motion That Council requests that the Mayor: Send a copy of the final approved recommendations related to Item 9.3.2 (C2024-1045) to the Government of Alberta and the Government of Canada through Minister… | Carried 15–0 |
Sep 17, 2024 Regular Meeting of Council | Main motion Direct Administration to: Include the costs of Green Line Program wind down in the Mid-Cycle Adjustments so there is transparency for the public on costs associated with termination of the Program… | Carried 10–5 |
Sep 17, 2024 Regular Meeting of Council | Amendment That Council insert the following as a new Recommendation 12: Direct Administration to: Include the costs of Green Line Program wind down in the Mid-Cycle Adjustments so there is transparency for t… | Carried 10–5 |
Sep 17, 2024 Regular Meeting of Council | Main motion That Council directs as follows: The City of Calgary re-affirms that we are committed to working collaboratively with the Government of Alberta to deliver a Green Line replacement LRT; That we requ… | Carried 8–7 |