Recorded votes on C2018-0128
Amendment at the Regular Public Hearing Meeting of Council, March 12, 2018. Defeated 5–10.
Result
Defeated 5–10
Margin -5
Absent
0
Meeting
Mar 12, 2018
Regular Public Hearing Meeting of Council
Topic
Housing & affordability
Assigned by keyword
Kind
Amendment
Resolution
That with respect to Councillor Sutherland's proposed amendment as follows, Council refer to Administration for further study and return to Council through the SPC on Planning and Urban Development as soon as possible: That with respect to Recommendation 3 to Report C2018-0128, Attachment 3, "Proposed Policy to Guide Discretion for Secondary Suites and Backyard Suites" be amended as follows: on Page 2 of 2, Section B, "Planning Principles for Secondary Suites and Backyard Suites", add a new Section B.5. "Secondary suites are encouraged to be above grade when located in flood fringe areas. Should the suites be located below grade, they must show that they are compliant with the flood mitigation rules."
Seats
YesNoAbsent (recorded)No vote recorded
Seats run Mayor, then Wards 1–14. Text and named votes from the confirmed Council minutes (linked above, at the source page).
How each member voted
| Seat | Member | Vote |
|---|---|---|
| Mayor | Naheed Nenshi | No |
| Ward 1 | Ward Sutherland | No |
| Ward 2 | Joe Magliocca | Yes |
| Ward 3 | Jyoti Gondek | No |
| Ward 4 | Sean Chu | No |
| Ward 5 | George Chahal | Yes |
| Ward 6 | Jeff Davison | Yes |
| Ward 7 | Druh Farrell | No |
| Ward 8 | Evan Woolley | Yes |
| Ward 9 | Gian-Carlo Carra | No |
| Ward 10 | Ray Jones | No |
| Ward 11 | Jeromy Farkas | Yes |
| Ward 12 | Shane Keating | No |
| Ward 13 | Diane Colley-Urquhart | No |
| Ward 14 | Peter Demong | No |
A roll call from the minutes. A member not listed was absent or did not vote; the minutes do not always say which.
Recorded votes on C2018-0128
| Meeting | Motion | Result |
|---|---|---|
Mar 12, 2018 Regular Public Hearing Meeting of Council | Amendment That with respect to Recommendation 3 to Report C2018-0128, Attachment 3, "Proposed Policy to Guide Discretion for Secondary Suites and Backyard Suites" be amended as follows: on Page 1 of 2, Secti… | Carried 11–4 |
Mar 12, 2018 Regular Public Hearing Meeting of Council | Amendment That with respect to Recommendation 3 to Report C2018-0128, Attachment 3, "Proposed Policy to Guide Discretion for Secondary Suites and Backyard Suites" be amended as follows: on Page 1 of 2, Secti… | Carried 11–4 |
Mar 12, 2018 Regular Public Hearing Meeting of Council | Amendment That with respect to Recommendation 3 to Report C2018-0128, Attachment 3, "Proposed Policy to Guide Discretion for Secondary Suites and Backyard Suites" be amended as follows: on Page 1 of 2, Secti… | Carried 8–7 |
Mar 12, 2018 Regular Public Hearing Meeting of Council | Amendment That with respect to Recommendation 3 to Report C2018-0128, Attachment 3, "Proposed Policy to Guide Discretion for Secondary Suites and Backyard Suites" be amended as follows: on Page 2 of 2, Secti… | Carried 11–4 |
Mar 12, 2018 Regular Public Hearing Meeting of Council | Amendment That with respect to Recommendation 2 to Report C2018-0128, the recommendation be amended as follows: 2 a) Give first reading to Bylaw 24P2018; and 2 b) Direct Administration to: i. explore an exem… | Defeated 6–9 |
Mar 12, 2018 (this vote) Regular Public Hearing Meeting of Council | Amendment That with respect to Councillor Sutherland's proposed amendment as follows, Council refer to Administration for further study and return to Council through the SPC on Planning and Urban Development… | Defeated 5–10 |
Mar 12, 2018 Regular Public Hearing Meeting of Council | Amendment That with respect to Recommendation 3 to Report C2018-0128, Attachment 3, "Proposed Policy to Guide Discretion for Secondary Suites and Backyard Suites" be amended as follows: on Page 1 of 2, Secti… | Defeated 7–8 |
Mar 12, 2018 Regular Public Hearing Meeting of Council | Procedural That subject to Section 6(1) of Procedure Bylaw 35M2017, Council suspend Section 79 in order to complete Item 4.1, Report C2018-0128 or end at 10:30 p.m. whichever comes first, prior to recessing f… | Carried 10–5 |
Mar 12, 2018 Regular Public Hearing Meeting of Council | Bylaw reading Adopt the proposed amendments to Land Use Bylaw 1P2007; and 2. Give three readings to Bylaw 24P2018 (Attachment 10); | Carried 9–6 |
Mar 12, 2018 Regular Public Hearing Meeting of Council | Main motion Adopt by resolution the proposed Policy to Guide Discretion for Secondary Suites and Backyard Suites (Attachment 3), as amended; | Carried 10–5 |
Mar 12, 2018 Regular Public Hearing Meeting of Council | Main motion Adopt by resolution the 2018 Planning Applications Fee Schedule (Attachment 6) to reintroduce fees; and, 7. Adopt by resolution the 2018 Planning Applications Fee Schedule (Attachment 7) to support… | Carried 9–6 |
Amendments, referrals and the main motion on the same report, oldest first.