Recorded votes on C2017-0003
Main motion at the Regular Meeting of Council, January 23, 2017. Carried 8–7.
Resolution
That with respect to Report C2017-0003, the following be adopted: WHEREAS, the public hearing for the redevelopment of the Highland Park golf course (C2017-0003 and LOC2014-0190) revealed a gap between results of the Transit Oriented Development (TOD) Charette and the administrative review of a specific land use application; and WHEREAS, the competing visions of the community and the developer have not been well reconciled in the final resulting land use recommendations, which do not adequately reflect the benefits of the TOD Charette; and WHEREAS, more specifically, the buffer has been favoured over the objectives of integrated TOD planning including the minimization of surface parking, minimization of building heights, minimization of required fill, use of slope adaptive design, and maximization of high quality public open space; and WHEREAS, a better result may have been achieved had a planning exercise such as an area redevelopment plan had been in place or such work undertaken; and WHEREAS, this is a part of the City that would greatly benefit from a long overdue planning review; NOW THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED, that Administration be directed to consider a Highland Park Area Redevelopment Plan (ARP) and subsequent city-initiated land use redesignations and report back to Council with a proposed work schedule in 2017 June on the North Green Line, such ARP and land use redesignations to be completed before or concurrent with the conclusion of the Highland Village Green storm water study.
How each member voted
| Seat | Member | Vote |
|---|---|---|
| Mayor | Naheed Nenshi | Yes |
| Ward 1 | Ward Sutherland | No |
| Ward 2 | Joe Magliocca | No |
| Ward 3 | Jim Stevenson | No |
| Ward 4 | Sean Chu | Yes |
| Ward 5 | Ray Jones | Yes |
| Ward 6 | Richard Pootmans | No |
| Ward 7 | Druh Farrell | Yes |
| Ward 8 | Evan Woolley | Yes |
| Ward 9 | Gian-Carlo Carra | Yes |
| Ward 10 | Andre Chabot | No |
| Ward 11 | Brian Pincott | Yes |
| Ward 12 | Shane Keating | No |
| Ward 13 | Diane Colley-Urquhart | No |
| Ward 14 | Peter Demong | Yes |
Recorded votes on C2017-0003
| Meeting | Motion | Result |
|---|---|---|
Jan 16, 2017 Combined Meeting of Council | Procedural That Item 6.1, C2017-0003 and Item 6.2, CPC2016-149, be tabled to be dealt with as the first two items of business on Tuesday, 2016 January 17. | Carried 8–7 |
Jan 23, 2017 Regular Meeting of Council | Main motion That Administration Recommendation 13 contained in Report C2017-0003 as amended, be further amended, as follows: In Attachment 6, on Page 12 of 14, Section 5.0, title ‘Access, Parking and Site Serv… | Defeated 6–9 |
Jan 23, 2017 Regular Meeting of Council | Bylaw reading That Administration Recommendations 1-12 contained in Report C2017-0003 be adopted, after amendment, as follows: That Council: 1. FILE the Calgary Planning Commission recommendation of CPC2016-149… | Carried 10–5 |
Jan 23, 2017 (this vote) Regular Meeting of Council | Main motion WHEREAS, the public hearing for the redevelopment of the Highland Park golf course (C2017-0003 and LOC2014-0190) revealed a gap between results of the Transit Oriented Development (TOD) Charette an… | Carried 8–7 |