Recorded votes on CPS2013-0413
Main motion at the Regular Meeting of Council, May 27, 2013. Carried 8–7.
Resolution
That SPC on Community and Protective Services Recommendation 1 contained in Report CPS2013-0413 be adopted, as amended, as follows: That Council: 1. Approve the recommendations of the Task Force on Shark Finning (Attachment, page 3), after amendment, as follows: A. On Page 3 of 83 Section 1, Task Force Recommendations, by amending Recommendation 1, as follows: “1. Table the Bylaw Sine Die and consider a viable alternative approach to sustainable sourcing.” B. On Page 3 of 83 of the Attachment, Section 1, Task Force Recommendations, by deleting Recommendation 4 in its entirety, as follows: “4. Form a panel of fishery and trade experts that will create, maintain, and annually update a list of shark and ray fisheries that are deemed sustainable, legal, and traceable.”. C. On Page 3 of 83 of the Attachment, Section 1, Task Force Recommendations, by amending Recommendation 5, as follows: “5. Consider providing support to develop a pilot project to investigate the traceability initiatives of other species, and to inform the design of a traceability scheme for shark or ray products of potential interest to the city of Calgary.”.
How each member voted
| Seat | Member | Vote |
|---|---|---|
| Mayor | Naheed Nenshi | Yes |
| Ward 1 | Dale Hodges | Yes |
| Ward 2 | Gord Lowe | Yes |
| Ward 3 | Jim Stevenson | No |
| Ward 4 | Gael MacLeod | No |
| Ward 5 | Ray Jones | No |
| Ward 6 | Richard Pootmans | Yes |
| Ward 7 | Druh Farrell | Yes |
| Ward 8 | John Mar | Yes |
| Ward 9 | Gian-Carlo Carra | Yes |
| Ward 10 | Andre Chabot | No |
| Ward 11 | Brian Pincott | Yes |
| Ward 12 | Shane Keating | No |
| Ward 13 | Diane Colley-Urquhart | No |
| Ward 14 | Peter Demong | No |
Recorded votes on CPS2013-0413
| Meeting | Motion | Result |
|---|---|---|
May 27, 2013 Regular Meeting of Council | Amendment That with respect to Recommendation 1 contained in Report CPS2013-0413, the Task Force Recommendations be amended as follows: On Page 3 of 83 of the Attachment, Section 1, Task Force Recommendation… | Carried 10–5 |
May 27, 2013 Regular Meeting of Council | Main motion That with respect to Recommendation 1 contained in Report CPS2013-0413, the Task Force Recommendations, as amended, be further amended as follows: On Page 3 of 83 of the Attachment, Section 1, Task… | Carried 9–6 |
May 27, 2013 Regular Meeting of Council | Amendment That the SPC on Community and Protective Services Recommendations contained in Report CPS2013-0413 be amended by adding a new Recommendation 2 as follows, and by renumbering the remaining Recommend… | Defeated 7–8 |
May 27, 2013 (this vote) Regular Meeting of Council | Main motion That SPC on Community and Protective Services Recommendation 1 contained in Report CPS2013-0413 be adopted, as amended, as follows: That Council: 1. Approve the recommendations of the Task Force on… | Carried 8–7 |
May 27, 2013 Regular Meeting of Council | Main motion That SPC on Community and Protective Services Recommendation 2 contained in Report CPS2013-0413 be adopted, as follows: That Council: 2. Direct the Administration to work with the Task Force member… | Carried 9–6 |
May 27, 2013 Regular Meeting of Council | Bylaw reading That SPC on Community and Protective Services Recommendation 3 contained in Report CPS2013-0413 be adopted, after amendment, as follows: 3. That if Bylaw 45M2012 returns to Council, that Council co… | Carried 9–6 |
May 27, 2013 Regular Meeting of Council | Main motion That SPC on Community and Protective Services Recommendation 4 contained in Report CPS2013-0413 be adopted, as follows: That Council: 4. Direct Administration to work with the Task Force to identif… | Defeated 7–8 |